14 Best Eye Cream for Dark Circles, Puffiness and Under Eye Bags - The Dermatology Review

14 Best Eye Cream for Dark Circles, Puffiness and Under Eye Bags



Aging causes skin to lose its elasticity, for the dermis to become thinner, for collagen fibers to unravel, all of which slowly but surely lead to sagging and wrinkling. But when it comes to eye area, you have that and then some: you also have to deal with dark circles and puffiness. Here’s the lowdown on how to tackle these two prominent skin issues.

Related: How to get rid of dark circles



Eye cream reviews


Why the Eye Area is More Prone to Aging

In the eye area, the signs of aging even more pronounced, as this delicate zone contains very little subcutaneous fat and is naturally very thin. It also does not proudce as much natural moisture as does the rest of your skin. This is why things like dark circles and puffiness are so easy to see.

Causes of Puffiness and Dark Circles

Puffiness and dark circles can be caused by lack of sleep, allergies and even, very unfairly, genetics. Skin thins as we age and important proteins like collagen and elastin begin to degrade from chronic UV exposure and the natural passage of time. Prevention can go a long way in combating these problems, but many of these creams were also developed to treat already existing issues.

Related: How to get rid of under eye bags

Popular Ingredients for Dark Circles and Puffy Eyes

Science has found a variety of ingredients, including caffeine, vitamins A, C and E, hyaluronic acid and various antioxidants to strengthen skin, depuff and brighten for refreshed and rejuvenated eyes.

Below are some of the ingredients you’ll notice again and again on this list, because they have been proven effective many times over. Caffeine is especially good at depuffing, and vitamins A, C and E (especially in combination) are skin lighteners and brighteners that reduce pigmentation. Wrinkle reducing and fortifying ingredients like hyaluronic acid and antioxidants are helpful because they strengthen the thin skin of the eye area to make it less translucent.

14 Best Eye Cream for Dark Circles, Puffiness and Under Eye Bags

Best Eye Creams

Clinique Even Better Eyes Dark Circle Corrector
This formulation has several ingredients for lightening skin that could be effective against dark undereye circles. Tocopherol acetate (vitamin E) has shown a depigmentation effect in studies by stopping the action of tyrosinase, an enzyme that boosts the production of melanin. The whey protein in this formula also contains glutathione, which has shown promise in clinical studies of also reducing discoloration. The depigmentation effects from both of these ingredients can help treat the darkness underneath the eyes to make the skin appear brighter and lighter. Palmitoyl oligopeptide stimulates collagen production, essentially fortifying skin. By strengthening the skin under the eyes, this cream helps skin become less transparent, which in turn keeps the capillaries and veins responsible for dark undereye circles less likely to show. Meanwhile, caffeine helps eyes de-puff, as does the soothing cool metal tip applicator. Gently rub the applicator tip back and forth along your undereyes to help puffiness go down.  

Ole Henriksen’s Banana Bright Eye Cream
In addition to hydrating ingredients like jojoba oil and shea butter, which provide an abundance of moisture, Ole Henriksen Banana Bright Eye Cream contains the potent depigmentation agent vitamin C. This well-researched vitamin has been shown in many studies to help halt the production of melanin, making it a great ingredient in helping to reduce darkness under the eyes. In fact, Ole Henriksen’s Banana Bright Eye Cream contains the most stable form of vitamin C, tetrahexyldecyl ascorbate. In studies it has shown depigmentation effects as well as the ability to stimulate collagen production, improving not only discoloration but wrinkling as well. Another ingredient, tocopherol acetate, or vitamin E, has also shown the ability to inhibit tyrosinase, the enzyme that promotes melanin production. Together, vitamins C and E are a potent combination, working even more effectively to reduce pigmentation. 

Vichy LiftActiv
The skin brightening and depuffing ingredients in Vichy LiftActiv include vitamin E (tocopherol acetate) and caffeine. As previously mentioned, vitamin E has shown depigmenting properties by blocking the tyrosinase enzyme that contributes to melanin production. This is significant as it can help reduce the dark discoloration that results in undereye darkness in the first place. The caffeine in this formulation works on depuffing and calming the undereye area to keep it from becoming filled with fluid and making the eyes look swollen and tired. Rhamnose, on the other hand, helps promote collagen synthesis. It has been shown effective in studies in “skin remodeling.” This ingredient can potentially strengthen skin layers to keep them from being transparent enough to show all the blood-filled capillaries that often exacerbate the look of dark undereye circles. All in all, this cream has proven active ingredients to help with dark circles and puffiness. 

Skinceuticals A.G.E. Eye Complex
The Skinceuticals A.G.E. Eye Complex is so-called because it is formulated to fight aging skin caused by advanced glycation end-products (AGE). AGEs accumulate as we age and can be very harmful. They are created when protein or fat combines with sugar, resulting in glycation. The body typically fights off these AGEs with antioxidants, which is very important, because high levels of AGEs can result in diseases like diabetes. When it comes to skin, AGEs are considered to accelerate aging and to lead to common skin problems like wrinkling and sagging. 

Key ingredients in the Skinceuticals A.G.E. Eye Complex include a combination of flavonoids, ascorbyl glucoside and optical diffusers designed to reduce the appearance of dark circles. Flavonoids are plant compounds that act as antioxidants to fight off free radicals and oxidative stress. Oxidative stress refers to an imbalance of free radicals and antioxidants in the skin. Regularly nourishing the skin with powerful antioxidants can help correct this balance. Flavonoids also help to stabilize collagen and elastin, two protein fibers crucial to skin structure. Basically, collagen and elastin keep skin firm and flexible, and a firmer eye area means less dark circle visibility. Ascorbyl glucoside is a form of vitamin C, an established and tested de-pigmenting agent that can lighten dark circles with regular use. Finally, the optical diffusers in this eye cream basically disperse light to reduce the appearance of uneven skin tone and discoloration. 

Bye Bye Under Eye Cream
There are so many great ingredients in IT CosmeticsBye Bye Under Eye Cream, we almost don’t know where to start. Perhaps we’ll begin by saying that the special blue tint in this eye cream helps to counteract the appearance of dark circles, making you look less tired and far more awake. That’s an immediate plus that many black circle sufferers will be pleased to note. After all, nothing quite makes you look older than looking tired. The collagen and caffeine in this formula help to firm up skin and depuff, respectively. By overall fortifying the delicate skin area, these two ingredients can take years off your eyes. Vitamin C is another noted and highly studied ingredient that helps to not only reduce pigmentation but also stimulate collagen production. Two birds, one stone. Retinol, another potent ingredient, gently exfoliates, fades discoloration and also stimulates collagen production to help strengthen and revive. A stronger skin matrix allows for less transparency as well.

Pigmentclar Eyes
La Roche-Posay’s Pigmentclar Eyes is an ideal solution for dark circles. It contains phe-resorcinol, a depigmentation agent the company says is 100x more powerful than kojic acid, itself a very potent depigmentation agent. L’Oreal, the parent company of La Roche-Posay, has conducted studies that show that phe-resorcinol can greatly minimize the appearance of dark spots, and so it’s included in the entire Pigmentclar line of products. Other active ingredients in this formulation include niacinamide, gingko biloba extract and caffeine. Niacinamide, or vitamin B3, has been shown in studies to treat hyperpigmentation, wrinkles, elasticity, sallowness (yellowing) and red blotchiness. The gingko biloba and caffeine in this formula help constrict blood vessels to keep them from darkening the undereye area. As for puffiness, it is reduced by the cooling and soothing metallic tip used upon application. The final step in producing vibrant eyes involves the use of light reflecting pearl pigments that diffuse light to brighten the undereye area.

Estee Lauder Advanced Night Repair Eye Serum
This is a serum developed for nighttime use. It is important to apply some creams during the night when they can absorb more readily into the skin because of increased blood flow. Nighttime is also when our skin repairs itself, and any help we can give it ourselves is quite important. The Estee Lauder Advanced Night Repair Eye Serum contains algae extract and a variety of plant extracts, including mulberry root, soybean, barley and chamomile. Algae extract is an antioxidant and humectant, which is a substance that can help bind water to the skin, effectively hydrating it. Mulberry root has been shown in studies to have skin lightening effects. Soybean extract is an antioxidant and anti-inflammatory that can help calm skin, thereby reducing puffiness. Barley extract has been known to provide a soothing effect in addition to being an antioxidant. Chamomile extract is a very powerful anti-inflammatory, shown in studies to be superior to hydrocortisone. These soothing antioxidants can all help with depuffing. Tocopherol acetate, or vitamin E, is another very strong antioxidant that has also shown skin lightening activity in studies. Caffeine rounds out the list by helping to depuff prominent undereye bags. 

Origins Ginzing Eye Cream
Origins Ginzing Eye Cream promises “to brighten and depuff” eyes that have become dark and swollen from fatigue and exhaustion. The main ingredient in this formulation is coffee. Caffeine helps alleviate water retention, the primary cause of puffy eyes. Even drinking it has shown to be able to achieve this feat. Undereye bags can also be caused by allergies and a bout of crying, both of which cause the eye bags to retain water. Research has also shown that caffeine can reduce puffiness and dark circles as well. Another helpful ingredient is cucumber fruit extract. Cucumber fruit extract has been shown in studies to reduce melanin content of the skin. This can help reduce the pigment in dark undereye circles and brighten the area. Cucumber also has a cooling effect that can help alleviate puffiness.

Algenist Complete Eye Renewal Balm
Algenist Complete Eye Renewal Balm is loaded with peptides, antioxidants and skin brighteners. Peptides are linked amino acids in a chain that can reduce the appearance of wrinkles in a number of ways. Some stimulate collagen while others help to relax facial muscles to decrease expression lines. In addition to reducing wrinkles, peptides can potentially strengthen skin, thickening it to make it less transparent. Less transparency in the eye area translates to less visibility of blood vessels, which can account for that dark look under the eyes. Moreover, the already thin skin around the eye area gets even thinner as we age, so it’s important to try to prevent this. 

In this formulation, tetrapeptide-21 stimulates collagen production, dipeptide-2 is said to improve lympathic circulation, which can potentially help with dark circles, palmitoyl tetrapeptide-7 is an anti-inflammatory that can potentially curb glycation, a natural process that damages skin structure, and palmitoyl oligopeptide is also said to stimulate collagen. This formulation also contains aloe barbadensis leaf juice and powder. This is a very soothing anti-inflammatory ingredient that can calm skin and reduce redness. Cucumber fruit extract can reduce melanin in the skin, making dark circles less obvious. Caffeine helps reduce puffiness by constricting blood vessels. Tocopherol acetate (vitamin E) and green tea leaf extract are both antioxidants that work to reduce free radical damage that causes wrinkling. There are definitely a lot of goodies in this formula that should calm, sooth and protect your eye area. 

Hyaluronic acid and caffeine are the main ingredients in NeoCutis’ MICRO EYES cream. It also includes peptides to help strengthen thinning skin and vitamin E for its antioxidant powers. Another key ingredient is a chamomile extract called bisabolol, which calms and refreshes. Hyaluronic acid is absolutely imperative for proper hydration. It retains 1,000 times its weight in water, which amounts to about six liters. That’s…A LOT. It’s this remarkable water retaining ability that makes it so great for providing adequate amounts of moisture to the skin. It also has the effect of plumping up lines to make them less noticeable. Caffeine temporarily constricts blood vessels around the eye area to make puffiness less conspicuous. Peptides, as previously mentioned, can help greatly with reducing wrinkle appearance by stimulating collagen synthesis. More collagen in the skin allows it to be stronger and thicker, which is ideal for the eye area as it is already very thin skin. Transparency can be reduced by fortifying this area, and thus allowing dark circles to be less prominent. One of the causes of dark circles is the appearance of blood vessels through the thin, almost sheer skin of the undereye zone. Vitamin E is a potent antioxidant, but it has also shown depigmenting abilities through its inhibition of tyrosinase, the enzyme responsible for melanin synthesis. This, as you can imagine, can also help reduce the appearance of dark circles.  

Bioelements Multi-Task Eye Creme
There are several key ingredients at work in the Bioelements Multi-Task Eye Creme. Phytonadione, or vitamin K, is the one that specifically targets dark circles. Vitamin K helps blood clot better and is an effective treatment against bruises. In studies, it has shown to be “moderately effective” for the treatment of dark circles when combined with retinol (vitamin A) and vitamins C and E. Consequently, this formulation also contains vitamins A, C and E. Cucumber and aloe vera are soothing ingredients that can reduce pigmentation and redness. This cream is also light and non-greasy and absorbs easily. 

SkinMedica TNS Illuminating Eye Cream
There are several interesting ingredients in this eye cream from SkinMedica. For starters, there is TNS, or human fibroblast conditioned media. TNS is a combination of several natural messenger proteins that has been shown in studies to improve “textural irregularities” and wrinkles. New collagen formation was also detected. This can potentially help firm up and strengthen the undereye area to prevent transparency. When it comes to dark circles, both N-Hydroxysuccinimide and chrysin combine to reduce them. N-Hydroxysuccinimide works by breaking down blood-originated pigments in the undereye area that are largely responsible for dark circles. Chrysin is an antioxidant and anti-inflammatory that helps reduce both dark circles and puffiness. It is also an effective skin conditioner, making it softer and helping to ease the appearance of wrinkles. The boron nitride in this cream helps disperse light, making dark circles less prominent and obvious.  

Best of the Best

Formulyst Anti-Dark Circle Eye Cream

Didn’t log enough zzzzs last night, and it’s showing up under your eyes? Smooth on Formulyst’s anti-dark circle eye cream. A combination of vitamins, amino acids and minerals targets dark circles and puffiness. Three of the cream’s most powerful ingredients are naturally derived- chenopodium quinoa seed extract, caffeine and butcher’s broom extract help to leave skin looking brighter and tighter.

Advanced Dermatology Youthful Boost Eye Cream
This formulation claims to treat dark circles and puffiness with a unique combination of tetrapeptides and plant extracts. Tetrapeptides help support natural collagen, which is very helpful for thinning skin, as thin skin can show even more of the blood vessels in the undereye area, accounting for dark circles. In fact, loss of elasticity and volume are major reasons why undereye circles develop in the first place, so looking for a cream with anti-aging benefits can be very helpful in dealing with this issue. The plant extracts in this cream are jojoba and Spilanthes acmella flower extract. The Spilanthes flower is also called the “toothache plant” thanks to its pain-relieving nature. In skincare products, it is a formidable foe for wrinkles, acting as a skin conditioning agent. Jojoba oil also nourishes and conditions to provide hydration. It also contains vitamin E, known for having a positive effect on dark circles. Furthermore, the hyaluronic acid in this formula helps hydrate eyes that may look especially puffy, tired and fatigued, whether it’s because you didn’t get a good night’s rest or you’re simply dehydrated. 

  • TDR 05.20.18 Reply

    Popular over-the-counter brands include Clinique, Shiseido, La Mer, Roc, Olay, Origins, La Prairie, Chanel, Obagi and Estee Lauder, but how do these products stack up against each other and how do drugstore brands compare to clinical products?

    You’ve probably heard about ingredients like vitamin C, vitamin K, retinol, caffeine, teamine, hyaluronic acid and peptides. How effective are these ingredients? What ingredients are effective at tightening and lifting the skin around the eyes?

    What is your favorite eye cream? Which formulations do you prefer?

    Next, write your own review.

  • TDR 05.20.18 Reply

    For some, they appear when you don’t get enough sleep. For others, they are always visible and worsen with age. Dark circles are one of the most common skin problems. To make things even worse, you probably have people telling you that you look tired, even though you had more than enough sleep.

    So what actually causes the problem? Truthfully, that depends on the color of the dark circles.

    Purple: Usually genetics. Common with individuals with darker skin tones.
    Red: Broken capillaries due to aging.
    Blueish: Lack of sleep. Too much rubbing. Irritation.
    Dark circles under the eyes can be effectively treated with a good under eye cream. For most individuals, dark circles aren’t the only issue.

    Look for brightening products that not only address pigmentation issues but also strengthen the skin around the eyes. Vitamin K is very effective. Also look for products that contain peptides, specifically peptides that support natural collagen production.

  • Your Review

    Recommended Articles