Most women who have lived in New York have made a pilgrimage to the original Kiehl’s store, on the corner of Third Avenue and 13th Street in the East Village. The skincare company started as an apothecary there in 1851, and built its brand on products such as Original Musk Oil, Calendula Herbal-Extract Toner as well as Ultra Facial Moisturizers. Kiehl’s is known for the pared down design of its ingredients which have a simple, clinical design that highlight the ingredients, and formulas that are based around botanicals. Today Kiehl’s has expanded across the globe and is now owned by L’Oréal, and some of its most popular products include its eye creams. Here’s a closer look at Kiehl’s eye products, their ingredients and are they right for you?
What Eye Creams Does Kiehl’s Sell?
Kiehl’s sells a wide variety of eye creams and serums designed to target everything from puffiness to fine lines and dry skin. Kiehl’s also sells eye creams specifically for men. Here’s a product breakdown:
Kiehl’s Midnight Recovery Eye – Designed to be applied at night, the Midnight Recovery Eye cream is meant to help reduce dark circles and puffiness around the eye. Key ingredients include butcher’s broom extract, lavender essential oil and evening primrose oil.
Kiehl’s Creamy Eye Treatment with Avocado – This pale green cream is formulated with avocado oil as well as beta-carotene, and is designed to hydrate the eye area. It can also be used as a quick eye mask.
Kiehl’s Youth Dose Eye Treatment – Formulated with pro-retinol, vitamin C and grape seed extract, this eye cream can be used twice a day to help de-puff eyes and smooth fine lines.
Kiehl’s Eye Fuel – Designed for men, Eye Fuel contains caffeine and vitamin B3 to help reduce dark circles and eye puffiness.
Kiehl’s Age Defender Eye Repair – This anti-aging eye cream for men is meant to lift, firm and reduce the appearance of dark circles thanks to rye seed extract and blurring minerals.
Kiehl’s Super Multi-Corrective Eye-Opening Serum – The eye area gets a boost with hyaluronic acid and botanical extracts, as well as illuminating minerals.
Kiehl’s Rosa Arctica Eye – The key ingredient in this anti-aging eye balm is the rare “resurrection flower” that is able to survive up to 31 hours of dehydration.
What Ingredients Are in Kiehl’s Beauty Products?
Kiehl’s says that 95% of its formulas contain at least one natural or natural origin raw material products. Its eye creams are formulated with botanical extracts as well as commonly used skincare ingredients such as hyaluronic acid, a moisturizing all-star as it can hold up to 1,000 times its weight in water, and retinol, a favorite wrinkle-fighter. The Creamy Eye Treatment with Avocado contains avocado oil, vitamins A, D, E and potassium. Rounding out the ingredients list is the antioxidant beto-carotene, and moisturizing shea butter. Rose arctica is the key ingredient in its namesake eye cream; also known as haberlea rhodopensis, it can survive nearly three months of dehydration. The Rose Arctiva Eye cream also contains white birch extract for hydration, and olive oil derived squalene. In addition to retinol, the Youth Dose Eye Treatment is powered by vitamin C and grapeseed extract. The Powerful Wrinkle Reducing Eye Cream’s key ingredients are Copper PCA, Calcium PCA, and caffeine to help reduce puffiness. The Powerful-Strength Line-Reducing Eye-Brightening Concentrate, a serum, is formulated with pure vitamin C (L-ascorbic acid which helps brighten the skin) as well as the haloxyl, which also helps lighten and brighten skin.
How Much Do Kiehl’s Eye Creams Cost?
Most Kiehl’s eye creams are priced between $30 and $50, which is in line with other prestige products sold in department stores. The Creamy Avocado Eye Cream is $48, while the Kiehl’s Midnight Recovery Eye is $37. Youth Dose Eye Treatment is $39 while Age Defender Eye Repair for men is $30. The Powerful-Strength Line-Reducing Eye-Brightening Concentrate retails for $44.
Where Can I Buy Kiehl’s Beauty Products?
Kiehl’s products are sold at its individual stores around the world, as well as department stores including Neiman Marcus, Lord & Taylor, Barneys, Macy’s and Nordstrom. It is also sold at Sephora and online at Walmart.
Is Kiehl’s Cruelty Free?
Kiehl’s is owned by L’Oréal, and according to the company, L’Oréal “does not test any of its products or any of its ingredients on animals and has been at the forefront of alternative methods for over 30 years.”
Do Kiehl’s Beauty Products Work?
When trying to decide if a product works, it’s important to keep in mind that everyone’s skin may react differently to the same product. One person’s miracle cream may cause a breakout in someone else, so a little trial and error is always needed when finding the right products for yourself. Kiehl’s eye creams certainly have a devoted following and have won industry recognition. In 2018, GQ magazine gave Kiehl’s Eye Fuel a Grooming Award. Kiehl’s Midnight Recovery Eye won a Best of Beauty award from Allure in 2013, and the magazine included Kiehl’s Youth Dose Eye Treatment in its roundup of “The 32 Best Eye Creams for Dark Circles and Puffiness” in 2019. Prevention magazine included the Kiehl’s Facial Fuel Eye De-Puffer in its 2019 list of “10 Best Eye Creams for Wrinkles, According to Dermatologists.”
In addition to industry awards, it’s also helpful to dive into customer reviews. The Creamy Eye Treatment with Avocado has nearly 800 reviews on Sephora, and over 30,000 “loves.” Customers give it 4.2 out of 5 stars, with fans saying “I have finally found an eye treatment which gives real results. I have jars and jars of eye creams from Tarte to Mario Badescu to L’occitaine. Nothing has ever impressed me as much as this!” and “Fantastic for dark circles! I received a sample of this and was blown away at how much brighter my under eye area looked within 5 minutes-and it lasted!” Customers who gave it a low rating complained that it did nothing for them, or caused irritation. “Did nothing for my dark circles, I have tan/olive skin and they still protrude through very dark. Plus, it applies very thick when you’re supposed to be sensitive in applying products on the under eye skin.”
The Midnight Recovery Eye has around 280 reviews on Sephora, with 20,000 loves and a 3.8 star rating. Those who liked it said “This stuff is amazing. It is truly the first eye cream that actually helps my hereditary dark circles” while those who were not impressed said they didn’t see any noticeable improvements to the eye area. “Too drying and didn’t help my dark circles” or it caused irritation – “Irritated my eyes. Made them itchy and puffy. Don’t bother.”
Other Kiehl’s eye creams don’t have as many reviews on Sephora. The Eye Fuel has only 11 reviews and gets 3.5 out of 5 stars. Feedback ranges from “I have had awful dark circles my entire life, and nothing has gotten rid of them. I tried this, and it is a miracle worker!!!!” to “2 uses and it broke me out in the eyeball region so I’ll be returning it. Can’t even use it long enough to see if it’s hydrating, depuffing or helps with dark circles.”
What Are Some Alternatives to Kiehl’s Eye Creams?
Kiehl’s eye creams may not be the right choice for everyone, because it may not react well with your skin or the price tag is too high. If you’re looking for skincare products to address the signs of aging, consider Formulyst and Advanced Dermatology.
Formulyst’s philosophy is long-term and effective skincare. The brand wants to help its customers achieve their best looking skin, rather than covering it up with makeup. The comprehensive line of products targets everything from wrinkles to dark spots and dry skin- as well as the delicate eye area.
Formulyst’s Anti-Dark Circle Eye Cream helps reduce puffiness and dark circles with the help of vitamins, amino acids and minerals. The potent cream contains three naturally-derived ingredients – chenopodium quinoa seed extract, caffeine and butchers broom extract – that work together to help leave the delicate eye area looking smoother and brighter.
Formulyst’s Complete Anti-Aging Eye Cream is a multi-tasking formula targeting the various signs of aging around the eyes. The powerful cream contains retinyl complex and peptide technology to help reduce the appearance of fine lines and wrinkles, while hyaluronic acid and cucumber extract soothe and hydrate the delicate eye area.
Fans of skincare kits, which take all the guesswork out of creating your own regimen, should try Advanced Dermatology. This no nonsense brand offers a pared down approach to skincare. The packaging is simple and streamlined, and the products bring skincare back to the basics. The kit contains just six essential items including a daily cleanser; serum; anti-wrinkle firming treatment; night cream; day cream and an eye cream. In other words, everything you need to achieve your best possible looking skin.