Colleen Rothschild Illuminating Tinted Eye Cream Review



Under-eye puffiness and dark circles are common skin concerns that can affect one’s appearance and overall confidence. Fortunately, skincare products are available that not only offer short-term solutions to disguise these concerns, but also incorporate ingredients to enhance the skin’s long-term appearance. 


1Carrot & Stick Review
-Colleen Rothschild Illuminating Tinted Eye Cream

One of those products is Colleen Rothschild Illuminating Tinted Eye Cream. It’s specifically formulated to improve the look of tired and dull eyes, targeting under-eye darkness, fine lines, dryness, and puffiness.

But is this Colleen Rothschild eye cream right for you? To help you decide, we’ll give you all the details on the key ingredients in this formula. We’ll also share some Colleen Rothschild reviews so that you can get an idea of what customers really think of this product. 

Is Colleen Rothschild Illuminating Tinted Eye Cream Right For You?

Before we get into the details, here’s the TL;DR if you just want to know whether or not Colleen Rothschild Eye Cream is right for you.

  • Key ingredients? Peptides, Caffeine, Pearlized Pigments
  • Skin type? All
  • Texture? Lightweight, silky cream
  • Fragrance? No
  • Cruelty free? Yes
  • Cost? $48 USD for 0.5 fl oz (15 mL)

What Are The Key Ingredients in Colleen Rothschild Illuminating Tinted Eye Cream?

In order to determine how well Colleen Rothschild Illuminating Tinted Eye Cream performs, we’ll have to evaluate the key ingredients in this formula. Let’s get started.


As you age, your body’s production of collagen and elastin slows down. These two proteins are responsible for your skin’s structural support. As a result, the skin loses its natural plumpness and smoothness. 

While collagen is necessary for maintaining youthful-looking skin, the collagen protein is too large to absorb into the skin topically. That’s why applying skin care products that contain collagen won’t provide the anti-aging benefits you’re looking for.

This is where peptides come into action. Peptides are the building blocks of protein, and they are easily absorbed into the deeper layers of skin due to their smaller size. 

Colleen Rothschild Illuminating Eye Cream contains five peptides, including palmitoyl pentapeptide-4, tripeptide-1, copper tripeptide-1, acetyl hexapeptide-8, and hexapeptide-9. 

If you’re looking for a peptide serum, we recommend Carrot & Stick The Repair Serum. It contains 7 plant-based peptides to promote plumper and smoother-looking skin. It also has skin-loving ingredients like hyaluronic acid and niacinamide.


Known for its energizing properties that help combat fatigue, caffeine is not only a morning pick-me-up but is also harnessed in eye creams to revitalize and “wake up” tired and fatigued eyes.

Caffeine functions as a stimulant when you ingest it, and that’s exactly how it works when you apply it to your skin. As a stimulant, caffeine causes vasoconstriction (constriction of the blood vessels) and stimulates blood flow when applied to the skin. This helps to tighten and firm the skin due to the removal of excess fluids and possible stimulation of the lymphatic drainage system.

It also aids in reducing the amount of blood that accumulates under the eyes (a major factor that contributes to dark circles). 

Furthermore, caffeine functions as an antioxidant, which means that it helps to protect the skin from free radical damage. 


One way this Colleen Rothschild eye cream helps to instantly disguise dark circles and brighten the under eye area is with various pigments in the formula. 

For example, pearlized pigments provide an instant brightening effect, creating a radiant, glowing appearance. 

Additionally, peach-colored pigments neutralize blue undertones, helping to balance out skin tone and create a more even appearance.

How to Use Colleen Rothschild Illuminating Tinted Eye Cream?

Apply under eye, gently tap and blend into the skin.

Where to Buy Colleen Rothschild Eye Cream?

This Colleen Rothschild eye cream and other Colleen Rothschild skin care products are sold on the brand’s website, as well as third party websites such as Neiman and

How Much is Colleen Rothschild Eye Cream?

Colleen Rothschild Illuminating Eye Cream costs $48 USD for 0.5 fl oz (15 mL). 

What is The Colleen Rothschild Return Policy?

The Colleen Rothschild return policy states, “While we hope that you love all our products, we know that sometimes that just isn’t the case! We are happy to offer exchanges or returns within 30 days of your purchase on all items. Unless you are setting up an exchange there is a $7 handling fee for all returns which will be deducted from your refund. Original shipping costs are non-refundable.”

Is Colleen Rothschild Beauty Cruelty Free?

Yes, Colleen Rothschild Beauty is cruelty free. 

Colleen Rothschild Illuminating Tinted Eye Cream Reviews

The reviews for this Colleen Rothschild eye cream are overall very positive, with the product receiving an average rating of 4.6 out of 5 stars after more than 300 customer reviews. 

There are many 5-star reviews for this Colleen Rothschild Eye Cream from customers who love that it’s lightweight and helps to brighten the under eye area. 

For example, one review says, “Delicate, non creasing and incredible brightness. Plays well with concealer or alone. Lifetime customer here.”

And another 5-star review says, “This eye cream immediately brightened up my under eyes. It took away the dark circles and made my face look fresh and my skin look healthier.”

However, there are a handful of negative reviews for the Colleen Rothschild Eye Cream, which are mostly from customers who noticed that the cream did not blend into the skin well or that it made wrinkles more emphasized. 

For example, one review says, “Not very happy with this purchase. The consistency is fine, but the color is very light & doesn’t blend into my skin at all.”

“I have to be honest, I did not like it. I am older and it emphasizes the wrinkles around my eyes. I purchased it due to a young influencer on Tik Tok. It looks so good on her.”

Our Verdict

Overall, we think that Colleen Rothschild Illuminating Tinted Eye Cream is formulated well, and we like that it offers both short-term and long-term benefits. 


  • Beneficial key ingredients (peptides, caffeine, pearlized pigments)
  • Many positive Colleen Rothschild Eye Cream reviews
  • Colleen Rothschild Beauty is cruelty free


  • Some reviews mention that it made wrinkles more noticeable

What Are Some Alternatives to Colleen Rothschild Eye Cream?

One alternative to this Colleen Rothschild eye cream that we recommend is Carrot & Stick The Eye Cream. The formula includes botanical extracts to minimize signs of stress and fatigue, including eye bags and dark circles. 

For example, persian silk tree extract has an anti-glycation effect that helps delicate skin around the lids feel tighter. Additionally, St. Paul’s wort helps sustain natural of collagen and elastin, restoring vitality.



Carrot & Stick

Carrot & Stick takes a tough love approach to skincare. What does this mean? It perfectly balances the power of plants with innovative science, offering the best of both worlds. Read More


The philosophy of Formulyst is long-term and effective skincare, rather than covering up any imperfections. The comprehensive line of products tackles everything from wrinkles to dark spots and dry skin. While some brands rely on unnecessary fillers and scents, Formulyst focuses on ingredients that help create results, such as vitamins, minerals and antioxidants. Read More

No comments yet

Your Review

Recommended Articles